Lenny & John Pizzeria & Restaurant

2036 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234 Order now
Hero image

Serving pizza on Flatbush Ave.

quotation

Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

Lenny & John Pizzeria & Restaurant Reviews on Grubhub

Jessica

Top Reviewer
Yesterday when we had company there was a problem when we ordered from their website but they were very apologetic & kind about it. The food was so good we wanted it again today and were not disappointed. I love that you can order specialty slices thru the app. For sure this will be our go to pizza and Italian food.

Damien

Top Reviewer
Once again, the order was very good. One of the best chicken rolls around and it took less then a 1/4 the time Grub hub predicted. I know chicken rolls don't take long but it seemed to come right out the oven when it got here. Highly recommend this place :)

Gio

2 reviews
My girlfriend suggested I get he chicken parm, and I was not this appointed! Everything tasted fresh especially the bread! I also had riceballs and surprised how good it was!

Jonathan

Top Reviewer
Their chicken rolls are always good, and their pizza is great when cooked well done. The dough is a little too chewy when cooked regular, but its still tasty either way.

Ben

Top Reviewer
Its all about Joe!
If he makes it, you'll love it. Grubhub doesnt do this place justice. You gotta visit to understand how great they are.
Thanks guys. Love you Joe!

Reviews from Seamless.com

Lenny & John Pizzeria & Restaurant Reviews on Seamless

dawnmichele

Top Reviewer
My food was late; I had to call to find out where it was. The bag came ripped with sauce dripping everywhere. The pizza is ice cold; the cheese is a slice. Called the pizza place and they girl asked me if I wanted a replacement order, which I dont not want to wait another 1hr and half to eat. I called Seamless who called Lenny and Johns for a refund and he was told If she wants her a refund, I want my food back. Disgusting. Come get your food, its in the garbage pail on my porch. I wish I could attach a picture to this. This is NOT THE WAY YOU TREAT NEIGHBORHOOD paying cash PEOPLE. POS.

Mark

2 reviews
This is the second time I ordered from L&J. Id like to think if I was Italian this is the kind of food I ate all the time! My food was piping hot when it arrived. The sauce on my baked ziti with sausage was not too salty and well seasoned. Nice amount of cheese, melted and gooey. The garlic bread is my kryptonite! Only feedback from me might be less blue cheese on the mesculin salad. My order arrived EARLY!

Emily

Top Reviewer
We had just gotten into an accident and were stuck waiting for the police to come for two hours. Our dinners plans were ruined and it was late, so I decided to just order a plain pizza from a random place I had never ordered from and I was bummed. The pizza was delivered very quickly and it was absolutely delicious. It really hit the spot and made a not-so-great night a little better. Would highly recommend!

Maylynn

Top Reviewer
My order came 45 minutes before the expected time, everything was correct, and the food was delicious as always! Reasonable prices, but good portions - this is my go-to Italian place to order from!

alex

Top Reviewer
Everything was awesome, the fried calamari, the calzone, the chicken Parmesan hero. It was all hot, fresh, and came way before the estimated delivery time, definitely ordering again.

About us

Chicken, Italian, Pasta, Pizza, Salads, Sandwiches, Seafood
Today
Delivery: 11:00 AM - 12:30 AM
Takeout: 11:00 AM - 12:30 AM

All of our dishes are made fresh and with the finest ingredients. We offer a tremendous selection of traditional Italian food, ranging from savory pasta dishes to homemade pizzas. If you're ready to experience the finest in Italian cuisine and delicious pizzas, visit Lenny and John's Pizza in Brooklyn, NY. Contact us or stop by Lenny and John's Pizza in Brooklyn, NY for a great taste of Italian foods from pizzas to baked ziti!